top of page

30 November 2023

13 Min. Read

Software development

TDD vs BDD: A Complete Comparison Guide

TDD vs BDD: A Complete Comparison Guide

Key Highlights

In this blog, we cover the following key highlights:

  1. Learn how TDD and BDD approaches are different and necessary at the same time.

  2. Get to know about the concepts involved in both the approaches.

  3. See TDD and BDD approach in action with some real examples.

  4. Learn how companies like InnovateX and TechFlow Inc. got benefited from adopting these approaches

Our whitepaper transforms the complexity in microservice testing into a manageable task, ensuring thorough testing that leaves no room for undetected bugs.

Software development has evolved significantly over the years, with methodologies focusing on enhancing efficiency and reliability. Two notable approaches in this evolution are Test-Driven Development (TDD) and Behavior-Driven Development (BDD).


Both aim to streamline the development process but differ in philosophy and execution. In this article, we'll explore both of these approaches in detail and examine how adopting either of them can benefit any development cycle.


TDD vs BDD

What is TDD?

In the fast-evolving landscape of software engineering, maintaining high code quality is paramount. Test-Driven Development (TDD) is not just a testing approach; it's a philosophy that encourages simplicity, clarity, and continuous improvement in software design.


At its core, TDD is a software development approach where tests are written before the actual code. It operates on a simple cycle:

👉Write a failing test,

👉write the minimum code to pass the test, and

👉refactor the code for better design.


TDD leads to a cleaner, more maintainable codebase. It encourages developers to think through requirements or design before writing the functional code, resulting in fewer bugs and more robust software solutions.


TDD Workflow

Red-Green-Refactor Cycle: This cycle starts with writing a test that fails (Red), then writing code that makes the test pass (Green), and finally refactoring to improve the code's structure (Refactor).


Imagine constructing a building: initially, you create a blueprint (the test), then you build according to the blueprint (write code), and finally, you enhance and beautify your construction (refactor).

# Python Example
def test_addition():
    assert addition(2, 3) == 5

def addition(a, b):
    return a + b

How to Perform TDD?

Test-Driven Development (TDD) is a software development process where tests are written before the actual code. The process typically follows a cycle known as "Red-Green-Refactor". Here's a step-by-step guide, along with an example using a simple function in Python:


Step 1: Understand the Requirement

Before writing any test, you must have a clear understanding of what the function or module is supposed to do. For example, let's consider a requirement for a function called add that takes two numbers and returns their sum.


Step 2: Write a Failing Test (Red Phase)

You begin by writing a test for the functionality that doesn't exist yet. This test will fail initially (hence the "Red" phase).

Example:

def test_add():
    assert add(2, 3) == 5

This test will fail because the add function doesn't exist yet.


Step 3: Write the Minimum Code to Pass the Test (Green Phase)

Now, write the simplest code to make the test pass.


Example:

def add(x, y):
    return x + y

With this code, the test should pass, bringing us to the "Green" phase.


Step 4: Refactor the Code

After the test passes, you can refactor the code. This step is about cleaning up the code without changing its functionality.


Example of Refactoring:

def add(x, y):
    # Refactoring to make the code cleaner
    return sum([x, y])

Step 5: Repeat the Cycle

For adding more functionality or handling different cases, go back to Step 2. Write a new test that fails, then write code to pass the test, and finally refactor.


Example: Extending the add Function

Let's say you want to extend the add function to handle more than two numbers.


New Test (Red Phase)

def test_add_multiple_numbers():
    assert add(2, 3, 4) == 9

Update Code to Pass (Green Phase)

def add(*args):
    return sum(args)

Refactor (if needed)

Refactor the code if there are any improvements to be made.

Interested in learning
how HyperTest can help you?

Get a Personalised Demo within 24 Hrs.

Best Practices To Implement TDD

Implementing Test-Driven Development (TDD) effectively requires adherence to a set of good practices. Follow through this list to get an idea:


  • Start with Simple Tests: Begin by writing simple tests for the smallest possible functionality. This helps in focusing on one aspect of the implementation at a time.


def test_add_two_numbers():
    assert add(1, 2) == 3

  • Test for Failures Early: Write tests that are expected to fail initially. This ensures that your test suite is correctly detecting errors and that your implementation later satisfies the test.


def test_divide_by_zero():
    with pytest.raises(ZeroDivisionError):
        divide(10, 0)
  • Minimal Implementation: Write the minimum amount of code required to pass the current set of tests. This encourages simplicity and efficiency in code.


  • Refactor Regularly: After passing the tests, refactor your code to improve readability, performance, and maintainability. Refactoring should not alter the behavior of the code.


  • One Logical Assertion per Test: Each test case should ideally have one logical assertion. This makes it clear what aspect of the code is being tested and helps in identifying failures quickly.


  • Test Behaviors, Not Methods: Focus on testing the behavior of the code rather than its internal implementation. This means writing tests for how the system should behave under certain conditions.


  • Continuous Integration: Integrate your code frequently and run tests to catch integration issues early.


  • Avoid Testing External Dependencies: Don't write TDD tests for external libraries or frameworks. Instead, use mocks or stubs to simulate their behavior.


  • Readable Test Names: Name your tests descriptively. This acts as documentation and helps in understanding the purpose of the test.


def test_sorting_empty_list_returns_empty_list():
    assert sort([]) == []

  • Keep Tests Independent: Ensure that each test is independent of others. Tests should not rely on shared state or the result of another test.


Common Challenges in Implementing TDD Approach

Implementing Test-Driven Development (TDD) can be a powerful approach to software development, but it comes with its own set of challenges. Here are some common obstacles encountered while adopting TDD, along with examples:


  1. Cultural Shift in Development Teams: TDD requires a significant mindset change from traditional development practices. Developers are accustomed to writing code first and then testing it. TDD flips this by requiring tests to be written before the actual code. This can be a hard adjustment for some teams.


  2. Learning Curve and Training: TDD demands a good understanding of writing effective tests. Developers who are new to TDD might struggle with what constitutes a good test and how to write tests that cover all scenarios.


  3. Integration with Existing Codebases: Applying TDD to a new project is one thing, but integrating it into an existing, non-TDD codebase is a significant challenge. This might involve rewriting significant portions of the code to make it testable. A large legacy system, for example, might have tightly coupled components that are hard to test individually.


  4. Balancing Over-testing and Under-testing: Finding the right level of testing is crucial in TDD. Over-testing can lead to wasted effort and time, whereas under-testing can miss critical bugs.


  5. Maintaining Test Suites: As the codebase grows, so does the test suite. Maintaining this suite, ensuring tests are up-to-date, and that they cover new features and changes can be challenging.


  6. Complexity in Test Cases: As applications become more complex, so do their test cases. Writing effective tests for complex scenarios, like testing asynchronous code or handling external dependencies, can be challenging and sometimes lead to flaky tests.


Adopting TDD is not just about technical changes but also involves cultural and process shifts within a team or an organization. While the challenges are significant, the long-term benefits of higher code quality, better design, and reduced bug rates often justify the initial investment in adopting TDD.


Benefits of TDD Approach

  1. Better Quality Software: Repeated refactoring results in enhanced code quality and adherence to requirements.

  2. Faster Development: TDD can significantly reduce bug density, thereby reducing the time and cost of development in the long run.

  3. Ease of Maintenance: The codebase becomes more maintainable due to fewer bugs.

  4. Project Cost Efficiency: It reduces the costs associated with fixing bugs at later stages.

  5. Increased Developer Motivation: The successful passing of tests instills confidence and motivation in developers.


Learn how adopting TDD approach led to a better product quality, faster releases, and higher customer and developer satisfaction for TechFlow Inc, which is a medium-sized development company.


What is BDD?

BDD is a software development process that focuses on the system's behavior as perceived by the end user. It emphasizes collaboration among developers, testers, and stakeholders.


Development begins by defining the expected behavior of the system, often described in a simple and understandable language, which is then translated into code.


Behavior-Driven Development (BDD) starts with clear, user-centric scenarios written in simple language, allowing for a shared understanding among developers, QA, and non-technical team members.


👉These scenarios are then converted into automated tests, guiding development to ensure the final product aligns with business goals and user needs.


👉BDD bridges communication gaps, encourages continuous collaboration, and creates living documentation that evolves with the project.


BDD Workflow

In BDD, scenarios are written in a human-readable format, usually following a "Given-When-Then" structure.


These scenarios describe how the software should behave in various situations.


👉Define behavior in human-readable sentences.

👉Write scenarios to meet the behavior.

👉Implement code to pass scenarios.


How to Perform BDD?

Behavior-Driven Development (BDD) is an extension of Test-Driven Development (TDD) that focuses on the behavioral specification of software units. The key difference between TDD and BDD is that BDD tests are written in a language that non-programmers can read, making it easier to involve stakeholders in understanding and developing the specifications. Here's a step-by-step guide on how to perform BDD, with an example using Python and a popular BDD framework, Behave.


Step 1: Define Feature and Scenarios

BDD starts with writing user stories and scenarios in a language that is understandable to all stakeholders. These are typically written in Gherkin language, which uses a simple, domain-specific language.


Example Feature File (addition.feature):


Feature: Addition
  In order to avoid silly mistakes
  As a math idiot
  I want to be told the sum of two numbers

  Scenario: Add two numbers
    Given I have entered 50 into the calculator
    And I have entered 70 into the calculator
    When I press add
    Then the result should be 120 on the screen

Step 2: Implement Step Definitions

Based on the scenarios defined in the feature file, you write step definitions. These are the actual tests that run against your code.


Example Step Definition (Python with Behave):


from behave import *

@given('I have entered {number} into the calculator')
def step_impl(context, number):
    context.calculator.enter_number(int(number))

@when('I press add')
def step_impl(context):
    context.result = context.calculator.add()

@then('the result should be {number} on the screen')
def step_impl(context, number):
    assert context.result == int(number)

Step 3: Implement the Functionality

Now, you implement the actual functionality to make the test pass. This is similar to the Green phase in TDD.


Example Implementation (calculator.py):


class Calculator:
    def __init__(self):
        self.numbers = []

    def enter_number(self, number):
        self.numbers.append(number)

    def add(self):
        return sum(self.numbers)

Step 4: Execute the Tests

Run the BDD tests using the Behave command. The framework will match the steps in the feature file with the step definitions in your Python code and execute the tests.


Step 5: Refactor and Repeat

After the tests pass, you can refactor the code as needed. Then, for additional features, you repeat the process from Step 1.


Best Practices To Implement BDD

  • Define Behavior with User Stories: Start by writing user stories that clearly define the expected behavior of the application. Each story should focus on a specific feature from the user's perspective.


  • Write Acceptance Criteria: For each user story, define clear acceptance criteria. These criteria should be specific, measurable, and testable conditions that the software must meet to be considered complete.

Example:

Given I am on the product page
When I click 'Add to Cart'
Then the item should be added to my shopping cart

  • Use Domain-Specific Language (DSL): Utilize a DSL, like Gherkin, for writing your behavior specifications. This makes the behavior descriptions readable and understandable by all stakeholders, including non-technical team members.


Feature: Shopping Cart
  Scenario: Add item to cart
    Given I am on the product page
    When I click 'Add to Cart'
    Then the item should be added to my shopping cart

  • Automate Acceptance Tests: Translate your acceptance criteria into automated tests. These tests should guide your development process.


Given(/^I am on the product page$/) do
  visit '/products'
end

When(/^I click 'Add to Cart'$/) do
  click_button 'Add to Cart'
end

Then(/^the item should be added to my shopping cart$/) do
  expect(page).to have_content 'Item added to cart'
end

  • Iterative Development: Implement features in small iterations, ensuring each iteration delivers a tangible, working product increment based on the user stories.


  • Refactor Regularly: After the tests pass, refactor your code to improve clarity, remove redundancy, and enhance performance, ensuring the behavior remains unchanged.


  • Encourage Collaboration: BDD is a collaborative process. Encourage regular discussions among developers, testers, and business stakeholders to ensure a shared understanding of the software behavior.


  • Focus on User Experience: Prioritize the user experience in your tests. BDD is not just about functionality, but how the user interacts with and experiences the system.


  • Documenting Behavior: Use the behavior descriptions as a form of documentation. They should be kept up-to-date as the source of truth for system functionality.


  • Avoid Over-Specification: Write specifications that cover the intended behavior but avoid dictating the implementation details. This allows developers the flexibility to find the best implementation approach.


Common Challenges in Implementing BDD Approach

While BDD offers many benefits, it also presents several challenges, especially when being implemented for the first time. Here are some of the common challenges associated with BDD:


  • Understanding and Implementing the BDD Process: BDD is more than a technical practice; it's a shift in how teams approach development. One common challenge is ensuring that all team members, not just developers, understand and effectively implement BDD principles.


For instance, non-technical team members might struggle with the concept of writing behavior specifications in a structured format like Gherkin.


  • Effective Collaboration Between Roles: BDD heavily relies on collaboration between developers, testers, and business stakeholders. Often, these groups have different backgrounds and expertise, which can lead to communication gaps.


  • Writing Good Behavior Specifications: Writing effective and clear behavior specifications (like user stories) is a skill that needs to be developed. Poorly written specifications can lead to ambiguity and misinterpretation.


  • Integrating BDD with Existing Processes: Introducing BDD into an existing development process can be challenging. It often requires changes in workflows, tools, and possibly even team structure.


  • Training and Skill Development: BDD requires team members to develop new skills, including writing behavior specifications and automating tests.


  • Balancing Detail in Specifications: Finding the right level of detail in behavior specifications is crucial. Too much detail can lead to rigid and brittle tests, while too little detail can result in tests that don’t adequately cover the intended behavior. Striking this balance is often a matter of trial and error.


Benefits of BDD Approach

  1. Wider Involvement: BDD fosters collaboration among various team members, including clients.

  2. Clear Objectives: The use of simple language makes objectives clear to all team members.

  3. Better Feedback Loops: The involvement of more stakeholders leads to comprehensive feedback.

  4. Cost Efficiency: Like TDD, BDD also reduces the likelihood of late-stage bugs.

  5. Team Confidence: Clarity in requirements boosts team confidence and efficiency.

  6. Ease of Automation/Testing: Documentation in BDD is more accessible for automation testers.

  7. Applicability to Existing Systems: BDD tests can be implemented at any stage of development.


Learn how adopting TDD approach led to a better product quality, faster releases, and higher customer and developer satisfaction for InnovateX, which is a medium-sized development company.


TDD vs BDD: What to choose?

The choice between TDD and BDD depends on various factors, including the project’s scope, team familiarity, and whether the system already exists. Both techniques have their place in software development and can be used together for optimal results in larger projects.


Here’s a summarized version of comparison between TDD vs BDD to help you get started with what works for you the best.


TDD vs BDD Comparison

Conclusion


In conclusion, TDD and BDD are powerful methodologies in the realm of software development. While they have their distinct features and benefits, they share the common goal of enhancing software quality and efficiency.


The choice between them depends on the specific needs and context of a project. Understanding their nuances is essential for software teams to leverage their strengths effectively.


Both methodologies aim to produce reliable, well-tested software, but they approach the problem from different angles and are suited to different environments and requirements.


Still unsure of which approach to adopt between tdd vs bdd? Click here to learn how these approaches helped companies like InnovateX and TechFlow Inc to accelerate their bug-free release cycles.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. What is the main difference between BDD and TDD?

Behavior-Driven Development (BDD) focuses on describing the system's behavior from a user's perspective using natural language, promoting collaboration between developers and non-technical stakeholders. Test-Driven Development (TDD) emphasizes writing tests before code to ensure functionality, aiding in design and refactoring. While both enhance software quality, BDD emphasizes collaboration and user-centric language, whereas TDD centers on code-centric testing.

2. What is an example of BDD?

In BDD, a scenario might be: "Given a user is logged in, when they click 'Purchase,' then the item should be added to their cart." This user-centric, natural language scenario exemplifies BDD's focus on behavior.

3. What are the key concepts of BDD?

Key concepts of BDD include writing scenarios in natural language to describe system behavior, using Given-When-Then syntax for clarity, fostering collaboration between developers and non-technical stakeholders, and emphasizing executable specifications. BDD aligns development with user expectations, promoting a shared understanding of desired outcomes.
bottom of page